ASKKINGSVILLE

INDEPENDENT. NOT THE TOWN.

Kingsville, Ontario

Get the briefing

← All stories

Official public records · Plain English

Council said four storeys. Then six. What happened on Main Street?

5 min read · Based on public records

In 2023, Council capped two stretches of Main Street at four storeys. Less than a year and a half later, it went back to six, by a single vote.

The limit

In September 2023, Council sat down to write new rules for how tall buildings could go along Main Street.

Town staff had suggested allowing up to six storeys in parts of it. Council went lower.

On Sept. 25, 2023, it set a four-storey limit in two areas:

Deputy Mayor DeYong moved the plan, and Councillor Patterson seconded it. It passed 6–1. Councillor Gaffan voted against.

Downtown stayed at three storeys. The west end, "Gateway West," kept six.

For the moment, four storeys was the rule. It wouldn't last.

The building at 183 Main

A month later, a six-storey, 42-unit building for 183 Main Street East came to Council.

Councillor Patterson moved to approve it, and Councillor Neufeld seconded. On Oct. 23, 2023, the motion failed 3–4. Councillors Lowrie, Neufeld and Patterson voted for it. Mayor Rogers, Deputy Mayor DeYong, Councillor Gaffan and Councillor Jarvis-Chausse voted against.

The building was turned down.

The vote was about more than height. The site holds the Esther Jasperson Campbell House, a heritage-designated home. The plan would have moved it about 13 metres closer to Main Street and restored it, with the new building behind it. The same failed motion would have approved that move, on condition that the house was moved and stabilized before construction began.

In July 2024, the Town issued a permit for the house covering a new foundation, moving it, and reconnecting water and sewer.

The builder didn't stop there. It appealed to the Ontario Land Tribunal, a provincial body that rules on planning disputes. Two developers also appealed the new four-storey limit itself.

Now the Town's decision was headed to a provincial tribunal.

The settlement

On Sept. 9, 2024, Council voted to settle.

Councillor Lowrie moved it, and Councillor Neufeld seconded. It passed 5–2, with Deputy Mayor DeYong and Councillor Gaffan against.

What did the deal do? A Town staff report later spelled it out. The building at 183 Main could go ahead. In return, the appeals against the Main Street limits were dropped. The published motion did not disclose the detailed settlement terms. The Tribunal issued its orders on Dec. 3, 2024.

The building Council had turned down was now going ahead. And the four-storey limit was next.

As of July 27, 2026, a Town planning review still listed "183 Main (Condos)" as approved: 0.42 hectares, 42 units and 100 units per hectare. It did not give a construction date.

The report

In January 2025, Town staff came back to Council with a recommendation: go back up to six storeys.

The report's own header says Jan. 13, 2024. It appears in the Jan. 13, 2025 Council agenda and discusses the December 2024 Tribunal decision and proposed 2025 by-laws, so AskKingsville treats the year on the report as a typo.

The report gave three reasons. It called the 2023 limit an "unexpected reduction." It said the limit had led to "costly appeals." And it said staff had "not found planning expert support" for it.

Staff also pointed out that six-storey buildings already stand at 190 Main Street and behind 195 Main Street, that other applications were already in the works, and that new provincial rules push for more housing on main streets.

This was a rule change for the whole Main Street area, not one developer's application. But staff said developer appeals were part of the reason for it.

On Jan. 13, 2025, five delegations spoke to Council. Four supported the change, and all four came from development or construction interests. One resident spoke against it.

Council didn't decide that night. Deputy Mayor DeYong moved to put it off a month, seconded by Councillor Patterson. It passed 5–1, with Mayor Rogers against. Councillor Neufeld was present but didn't vote.

The vote

On Feb. 10, 2025, it came back.

Before the vote, six residents spoke as delegations: five opposed the change and one supported it.

First, Council had to agree to reopen its own 2023 decision. Councillor Patterson moved it, and Councillor Neufeld seconded. It passed 6–1, with Councillor Gaffan against.

Then came the real question: six storeys.

Councillor Neufeld moved it, and Councillor Patterson seconded.

It passed 4–3.

One vote the other way, and Main Street would have stayed at four.

The catch

Council's vote wasn't quite the last word.

The change is in two parts: an update to the Official Plan, the Town's long-term land-use plan, and a matching zoning by-law. The zoning by-law says it doesn't take effect until the County of Essex approves the Official Plan change.

We haven't been able to confirm that the County has approved it. We also found no later Council vote changing the limits.

What Council's 2025 changes set

Six storeys is the most allowed, not a requirement.

What it means for you

How Council voted

Motion Date Moved by Seconded by Result For Against Other
Main Street plan with 4-storey limit Sept. 25, 2023 DeYong Patterson Passed 6–1 Rogers, DeYong, Jarvis-Chausse, Lowrie, Neufeld, Patterson Gaffan —
Approve the 183 Main building Oct. 23, 2023 Patterson Neufeld Failed 3–4 (building turned down) Lowrie, Neufeld, Patterson Rogers, DeYong, Gaffan, Jarvis-Chausse —
Settle the 183 Main appeal Sept. 9, 2024 Lowrie Neufeld Passed 5–2 Rogers, Jarvis-Chausse, Lowrie, Neufeld, Patterson DeYong, Gaffan —
Put the decision off a month Jan. 13, 2025 DeYong Patterson Passed 5–1 DeYong, Gaffan, Jarvis-Chausse, Lowrie, Patterson Rogers Neufeld present, didn't vote
Reopen the 2023 decision Feb. 10, 2025 Patterson Neufeld Passed 6–1 Rogers, DeYong, Jarvis-Chausse, Lowrie, Neufeld, Patterson Gaffan —
Raise to six storeys Feb. 10, 2025 Neufeld Patterson Passed 4–3 Rogers, Lowrie, Neufeld, Patterson DeYong, Gaffan, Jarvis-Chausse —

Where the public record stops

Official sources

  1. Council minutes, Sept. 25, 2023 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2023-09-25-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/187851d9-3f29-4e8d-a102-b0980102b224
  2. Council minutes, Oct. 23, 2023 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2023-10-23-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/b86fd795-2d88-449a-935b-b0c9015ade00
  3. Council agenda and staff report for ZBA-2023-14, Oct. 23, 2023 — staff report p. 2; Planning Justification Report p. 10 — https://kingsville-pub.escribemeetings.com/filestream.ashx?DocumentId=29906
  4. Council minutes, Sept. 9, 2024 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2024-09-09-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/176a22bc-d24d-4dd6-ba78-b1f80105284c
  5. Council agenda and staff report "Main Street Neighbourhood and Gateway – Building Heights," Jan. 13, 2025 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2025-01-13-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/14d5519d-6b6c-4c59-87a3-b25f0164b2a7
  6. Council minutes, Jan. 13, 2025 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2025-01-13-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/2fcfd405-dc3c-4a22-8eb5-b27300f7823d
  7. Council agenda, Feb. 10, 2025 (By-laws 4-2025 and 5-2025) — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2025-02-10-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/083fc2ec-7a9f-4467-81ea-b27e011c6398
  8. Council minutes, Feb. 10, 2025, section G (Delegations), page 2 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2025-02-10-1800-Regular-Council-Meeting/1b582254-053a-49ae-aa32-b2a40128ae69
  9. Local Settlement Area Review, July 27, 2026, agenda p. 88 — https://calendar.kingsville.ca/council/Detail/2026-07-27-1800-Special-Meeting-of-Council/5d058d95-7351-4636-93dc-b490000e6291
  10. Town Questions for Staff response by the Chief Building Official; page last updated Aug. 6, 2026 (web page, no page number) — https://haveyoursaykingsville.ca/questions-for-town-staff?tool=qanda
  11. Ontario Land Tribunal files OLT-23-001148 and OLT-23-001149
  12. Town Official Plan (2023) — https://www.kingsville.ca/en/resourcesGeneral/Plans-and-Studies/official-plan-2023.pdf

← Back to topics